Skip to the main content
HopTireGet my price

Guide

Pothole damage to a tire: where to file a claim, and by when

Deal with the tire first, report the pothole, then file a written claim with the road's owner before its deadline. Where to file and by when in 25 metros.

Your tires, handled. Service at your car. A real person on your side.

Checked 2026-09-22 · Updated 2026-11-11

Where is the car parked?

 

Any US ZIP. No account needed.

225/65R17

Deal with the tire first. Then report the pothole to the agency that owns the road, keep the case number, and file a written claim with that agency before its deadline. The table below gives where to file and by when in 25 metros, and the notes under it quote the rules that turn on whether the agency knew about the pothole.

First, the tire

Do not drive on a tire that took a hard pothole hit even if it still looks round. A sidewall bulge, a bent wheel, or a slow leak that starts hours later are common after a pothole strike and are not always visible at the roadside. Pothole tire damage: what to check and bubble in tire tread cover the warning signs. If the tire is flat now, flat tire in the driveway covers the safe next step. Repair or replacement, when we come to you, runs $169 for the first tire and $50 for each additional one, tax added at checkout, and if the inspection finds the tire unrepairable the $99 inspection visit is the only charge, with the rest refunded. Filing a city claim and booking the repair are two separate, independent steps; you do not need the claim resolved before you get the tire fixed, and the claim does not depend on which shop or mobile service did the work.

What to put in the claim

  1. The exact location and date/time. Not "near the intersection," but the address or nearest cross street, and which lane or side of the road.
  2. Photos of the pothole itself, ideally before it gets patched, plus photos of the tire and wheel damage.
  3. A repair estimate or paid invoice from the shop or service that fixed it. Some ask for more: Detroit's claim form and Houston's claim page ask for three estimates, and Columbus's form for two.
  4. Proof the agency knew, where its rule asks for it. A prior 311 or other complaint about that same pothole (yours or someone else's), or a prior repair request.

Where to file, and the deadline, by metro

Metro File with Typical deadline
New York NYC Comptroller (eClaim, or the paper Notice of Claim) 90 days from the incident
Chicago Office of the City Clerk, Claims Division Report promptly; claim reviewed by the Committee on Finance
Pittsburgh Department of Law, Report of Claim form File promptly after a 311 report; the pothole must have gone unpatched 5+ days after being reported
Dallas Office of Risk Management, Notice of Claim 6 months from the incident
Denver City Attorney's Office, Notice of Claim 182 days from discovering the damage
Los Angeles Office of the City Clerk, Claim for Damages (Form 100-A) 1 year for property damage
Atlanta Mayor or President of the Atlanta City Council, written claim 6 months from the incident
Boise City Clerk's Office, Claim for Damage form 180 days from the incident
Chattanooga City Attorney via 311/claims portal 12 months (Tennessee Governmental Tort Liability Act)
Savannah Clerk of Council, Damage and Claim Petition 6 months from the incident (Georgia claim rules apply the same way as Atlanta)
Austin City of Austin Law Department, Attn: Claims (email, mail or fax) 45 days, verified by affidavit (City Charter Art. XII, s. 3)
Baltimore Department of Law, Central Bureau of Investigation (automobile claim form), hand-delivered or by certified mail, return receipt requested Within one year of the incident. The City says it must receive the claim by then; Md. Courts and Judicial Proceedings 5-304 requires notice within one year
Boston City Clerk's Office, City Hall Room 601: a signed claim in hard copy, in person or by mail; $15 filing fee Received within 30 days of the incident for road and sidewalk defects (M.G.L. c. 84, s. 18)
Charlotte City Risk Management Office, General Liability Claim Form (the office also handles Mecklenburg County and Board of Education claims) None stated on the City's claim page or form
Columbus Department of Public Service: call 311 first and place a service request; a claim packet is then mailed. The form says to file with your own insurance company first None stated on the City's claim page
Detroit Law Department, Claims Section, notarized Claim Form The form: "Notice of Claim Must Be Filed Not Later Than 45 Days from the Date of Accident". MCL 691.1404(1): notice "within 120 days from the time the injury occurred"
Houston City Secretary's Office, with a copy to the City Attorney's Claims/Subrogation Section: written notice signed before a notary 90 days (City Charter Art. IX, s. 11). The City's FAQ also says: "Under State law, the City is not liable for property damage caused by the condition of its streets."
Indianapolis Tort Claims, City of Indianapolis, on the City's Notice of Tort Claim form, which "must be delivered in person or by registered or certified mail" 180 days after the loss
Minneapolis Risk Management and Claims, online claim form 180 days. The City's page counts from the event; Minn. Stat. 466.05 counts from when the loss "is discovered"
Nashville Metro Department of Law, Claims Division (online claims form) None stated on Metro's claims page
Philadelphia Office of Risk Management, Claims Unit (General Claim Form) Within six months of the incident. The City says its office must receive the form by then; 42 Pa.C.S. 5522 sets the six-month notice
Portland City of Portland Risk Management, General Liability Claim Form 180 days from the incident (ORS 30.275)
Raleigh City of Raleigh Risk Management Division, "Claim and Notice of Injury/Property Damage" form, online or PDF None stated on the City's claim page or form
Seattle City Clerk's Office: Claim for Damages form, or the City's online Claims Portal Within the state statute of limitations (the City points to RCW 4.16; RCW 4.16.080(2) gives three years for an action for "injuring personal property"); no lawsuit until 60 days after the claim is filed
Washington DC Office of Risk Management (eFiling Portal, or the claim form by mail or hand delivery) Written notice within six months after the damage (D.C. Code 12-309)

Some rules turn on whether the agency knew about the pothole before the damage. These sources say so in their own words:

  • Boston (M.G.L. c. 84, s. 15): recovery depends on whether the city "had or, by the exercise of proper care and diligence, might have had reasonable notice of the defect or want of repair", and a city is not liable "more than one fifth of one per cent of its state valuation last preceding the commencement of the action nor more than five thousand dollars".
  • Detroit (MCL 691.1403): "No governmental agency is liable ... unless the governmental agency knew, or in the exercise of reasonable diligence should have known, of the existence of the defect and had a reasonable time to repair the defect", and "Knowledge of the defect and time to repair the same shall be conclusively presumed when the defect existed so as to be readily apparent to an ordinarily observant person for a period of 30 days or longer before the injury took place."
  • Houston (City Charter Art. IX, s. 12): no liability for streets "being out of repair ... unless the same shall have remained so for ten days after special notice in writing given to the Mayor or city council."
  • Philadelphia (42 Pa.C.S. 8542(b)(6)(i)): the claimant must establish that "the local agency had actual notice or could reasonably be charged with notice under the circumstances of the dangerous condition at a sufficient time prior to the event to have taken measures to protect against the dangerous condition."
  • Columbus (the City's File a Claim page): "the party claiming damages must prove that either: the City had actual or constructive notice of the pothole and failed to respond in a reasonable amount of time, or responded in a negligent manner; or that the City, in a general sense, maintains its roadways negligently."
  • Portland and Raleigh ask. Portland's pothole claim page says City Risk will confer with PBOT on three questions: "Is it on a street the City is responsible to maintain?", "Has the pothole been reported?" and "Has the pothole been repaired?" Raleigh's claim form asks "How long has defective condition existed?" and "Was City notified of defect causing this accident prior to the accident?"

Deadlines and forms change; confirm the current version on the agency's own page before you file. The rows from New York to Savannah are dated 2026-09-22; the rows from Austin to Washington DC were read on 2026-11-10.

When the road is the state's

Some roads inside a city are state highways, and the state has its own claim route. What the sources say:

  • Indiana: INDOT maintains "interstates, U.S. routes and state roads". Its claim form, State Form 54668, goes to the Office of the Attorney General, and IC 34-13-3-6 bars a claim against the state "unless notice is filed with the attorney general or the state agency involved within two hundred seventy (270) days after the loss occurs."
  • Maryland: State Government 12-106(b), in the Maryland Tort Claims Act: "a claimant may not institute an action under this subtitle unless: (1) the claimant submits a written claim to the Treasurer or a designee of the Treasurer within 1 year after the injury to person or property that is the basis of the claim".
  • Massachusetts: the City of Boston says some streets in the city are under the control of MassDOT or the Department of Conservation and Recreation (DCR), and its Streetbook records street ownership. For state highways, M.G.L. c. 81, s. 18 refers to the "limitations, conditions and restrictions specified in sections fifteen, eighteen and nineteen of chapter eighty-four", says the amount "shall not exceed one fifth of one per cent of the valuation of the town in which the injury was received, nor shall it exceed four thousand dollars", and says: "Notice of the injury as required by law shall be given to a member of the department."
  • Michigan: MDOT says pothole claims "should only be submitted to MDOT if damage occurred on a state trunkline (M, I or US route), not local or county roads", on Form 3600 to the region office where the damage occurred; inside Detroit, that is the Detroit TSC. MDOT: "If your alleged damage claim is $1,000 or more, you can recover only by filing a lawsuit against MDOT." MCL 691.1402(2): "A municipal corporation has no duty to repair or maintain, and is not liable for injuries or damages arising from, a portion of a county or state highway."
  • Minnesota: MnDOT: "MnDOT is negligent ONLY if MnDOT had prior notice of the condition and a reasonable period of time to repair, correct, or warn of the condition." Minn. Stat. 3.736, subd. 5 sends notice to "the attorney general ... within 180 days after the alleged loss or injury is discovered".
  • North Carolina: G.S. 160A-296(a) gives a city "general authority and control over all public streets ... within its corporate limits except to the extent that authority and control over certain streets and bridges is vested in the Board of Transportation." Charlotte's 311 records file pothole requests as "CDOT POTHOLE REPAIR" or "NCDOT POTHOLE REQUEST" (City of Charlotte Open Data Portal, CC BY 4.0). Raleigh says: "To determine if a street or right or way is maintained by the City, visit the Interactive Street Maintenance Map or call 919-996-6446." For an NCDOT road, NCDOT offers "Submit a Claim Online" or a "Citizen Incident Statement" mailed "to the N.C. Department of Transportation in the county where the damage occurred". NCDOT "generally submits the driver's claim, as well as its own report, to the N.C. State Attorney General's Office, which will determine whether NCDOT knew about the pothole and made an effort to repair it within a reasonable length of time." If that office denies the claim, "drivers can appeal to the N.C. Industrial Commission." G.S. 143-299: "All claims against any and all State departments, institutions, and agencies shall henceforth be forever barred unless a claim be filed with the Industrial Commission within three years after the accrual of such claim".
  • Ohio: ODOT says it "is responsible for the State System of roads-- which includes all Interstates, as well as U.S. and State Routes outside of municipalities", and: "Claims may be filed with the Ohio Court of Claims." The Court of Claims: "If the amount of money you are seeking is $10,000 or less, your case will be assigned to the small claims category of cases known as Administrative Determinations", and "the Filing Fee is $25".
  • Oregon: ORS 30.275(5)(a) sends notice of a claim against the state "to the office of the Director of the Oregon Department of Administrative Services"; ODOT's Claims link points to DAS Risk Management.
  • Pennsylvania: 42 Pa.C.S. 8522(b)(5), on potholes on highways "under the jurisdiction of a Commonwealth agency", asks the claimant to establish that the agency "had actual written notice of the dangerous condition of the highway a sufficient time prior to the event", and ends: "Property damages shall not be recoverable under this paragraph."
  • Washington: RCW 4.92.100: "All claims against the state ... for damages arising out of tortious conduct, must be presented to the office of risk management."

Be realistic about the odds

Reporting outlets in more than one city in the table have found that the majority of pothole damage claims are denied, and Atlanta's reported approval rate was under 25% in local reporting. Two agencies say it themselves. Portland: "Most pothole claims are not paid. Historically, less than 10% of claims for potholes are due to city negligence." MDOT: "the majority of damage claims are denied under governmental immunity laws, MCL 691.1402 and MCL 691.1403." That is not a reason to skip filing; it is a reason to file with the strongest record you have of the specific pothole.

Questions people ask

  • Do I need a police report to file a pothole claim? Check the claim form for your city. Houston's claim page asks for an accident report "if available". In Washington DC, D.C. Code 12-309 says: "A report in writing by the Metropolitan Police Department, in regular course of duty, is a sufficient notice under this section."
  • What if I never reported the pothole before I hit it? You can still file. Check the notice rule for your city under the table; some include what the agency should have known, not only what was reported to it, for example Detroit's (MCL 691.1403).
  • Can I file if the pothole is on a state highway, not a city street? File with the agency that owns the road; see when the road is the state's. Atlanta's own guidance, for example, notes GDOT handles interstates and state routes, not the city.
  • Does keeping the damaged tire help the claim? It can. Some adjusters want to see the actual tire or wheel, not just photos, so ask the shop to hold it until your claim is resolved if you plan to file.
  • How long does a decision take? It varies. Los Angeles cites roughly 45 days by statute; Denver notes the city has 90 days to respond and treats no response as a rejection; Indianapolis's page says "By law, a claim is denied if not settled within 90 days"; Portland asks you to "allow at least 45 days"; MDOT says investigations of claims under $1,000 "typically take at least 90 days". Charlotte's Risk Management page says "This process can take 4-6 weeks or longer depending upon the nature of your claim"; Raleigh's says "this process can take up to 30 days or longer depending on the nature of your claim." In Seattle, a lawsuit may not start until 60 days after the claim is filed.
  • If the claim is denied, is that the end of it? Not necessarily; a denial is often the point where people consult an attorney about small-claims court or a formal appeal, which is outside the scope of this page. The claim forms above are the starting point either way.

Your tires, handled.

Service at home or work, with a real person to help you through it. Choose your service and see your price.

See my instant price →